By Alan Mozes HealthDay Reporter
“The relationship between social media and mental health has been the subject of a lot of debate,” said Dr. Roy Perlis, lead author of the new study. He’s director of the Center for Experimental Drugs and Diagnostics at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.
On one hand, social media is a way for people to stay connected to a larger community and get information about things that interest them, Perlis noted. On the other, even before widespread misinformation on these platforms was recognized, there was a sense that young people might be negatively affected.
But in multiple surveys over 12 months, depression status had worsened in some respondents, the study found. The risk rose with use of three hugely popular social media sites: Snapchat, Facebook and TikTok.
As to whether social media actually causes depression, Perlis said it’s unclear which is the chicken and which is the egg.
“One possible explanation for our results,” he noted, “is that people who are at risk for depression, even if they’re not currently depressed, are more likely to use social media. Another is that social media actually contributes to that increased risk.”
But this study wasn’t designed to distinguish between the two, he said.
To explore adult vulnerability, Perlis’ team focused on social media users 18 and up (average age: nearly 56). About two-thirds were women, and more than three-quarters were white people.
All completed an initial survey about their use of platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, Pinterest, TikTok, Twitter, Snapchat and/or YouTube.
Increased risk was seen in users of TikTok or Snapchat who were 35 years old and up, but not among younger users. The reverse dynamic played out with Facebook users: Depression risk went up among those under 35, but not among older users.
Given that specific cause and effect aren’t clear, Perlis said the takeaway for now is that researchers need to understand the relationship between social media and mental health better.
“Even if social media use is only telling us about underlying risk rather than causing it, can we understand why? Might we be able to intervene to prevent depression and anxiety?” Perlis asked.
He hopes his work will lead to some answers.
“We hope that our work will inform both mental health researchers and policymakers in thinking about how to study and potentially act on this relationship,” Perlis said.
One such researcher commended the new research for doing just that.
“The findings of the current study are consistent with other studies investigating the relationship between depressive symptoms and social media use,” said Amanda Giordano, an associate professor of counseling and human development services at the University of Georgia.
Giordano also echoed the need for caution in examining what’s causing what, and offered a number of theories.
“One hypothesis for the association between social media use and depressive symptoms is the act of comparing ones’ imperfect life to the enhanced, edited and seemingly perfect images of others’ lives,” she said. “This alone may not be the cause of depressive symptoms, but in individuals with other risk factors and predispositions, social media use could contribute to the development of symptoms.”
Another theory is that online social connections don’t adequately replace the depth and quality of offline friendships, Giordano said. As a result, even individuals with thousands of social media connections can still feel lonely, unknown and unsupported, she explained.
“Simply put, virtual connections may fail to meet our basic needs of belonging and attachment, which may contribute to depressive feelings in some individuals,” Giordano said.
The findings were published Nov. 23 in JAMA Network Open.
SOURCES: Roy Perlis, MD, MSc, professor, psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, and director, Center for Experimental Drugs and Diagnostics, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston; Amanda Giordano, PhD, associate professor, counseling and human development services, University of Georgia, Athens; JAMA Network Open, Nov. 23, 2021
Copyright © 2021 HealthDay. All rights reserved.